The Courage to Be Wrong

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5moOviRORLw

By William J. McNamara Jr.

There is something peculiar about the way we approach disagreement today.

We have access to more information than any generation in human history. We can research almost any subject, hear from people around the world, and examine perspectives that our ancestors might never have encountered.

And yet, with all that information, we seem less willing than ever to consider that we might be wrong.

Think about the last argument you witnessed.

Perhaps it was about politics. Perhaps it was something happening at work, a disagreement between family members, or one of the countless arguments taking place on social media.

How often did you see someone genuinely listening to understand the other person’s position?

How often did you see someone acknowledge a reasonable point made by the person they disagreed with?

And how often did you see someone actually change their mind?

Instead, we frequently see people defending their positions with increasing hostility, even when presented with information that should at least cause them to reconsider.

Somewhere along the way, we confused being right with being wise.

And those are not necessarily the same thing.

Being right about something doesn’t automatically make us wise.

We can arrive at a correct conclusion through incomplete reasoning, coincidence, or simply accepting what someone else told us.

Wisdom requires something more.

It requires understanding.

It requires judgment.

And perhaps most importantly, it requires recognizing that our understanding may be incomplete.

This is hardly a new problem.

Our Germanic ancestors understood that human beings were perfectly capable of mistaking confidence for wisdom.

The Hávamál, the Sayings of the High One, attributed to Odin, addresses this problem repeatedly.

Consider stanza twenty-six, as translated by Henry Adams Bellows:

An ignorant man | thinks that all he knows,
When he sits by himself in a corner;
But never what answer | to make he knows,
When others with questions come.

There is something remarkably familiar about that observation.

A person sitting alone, confident in everything he believes, until someone begins asking questions.

Suddenly, the certainty that seemed so secure becomes considerably less comfortable.

And notice something important about the passage.

It doesn’t say the man is foolish simply because he lacks knowledge.

Everyone lacks knowledge about something.

The problem is that he believes his understanding is complete.

He has mistaken the limits of his own experience for the limits of what can be known.

Now consider how easily we can fall into that same trap today.

We have created environments where it is possible to surround ourselves almost entirely with people who agree with us.

We follow commentators who reinforce our opinions.

We join groups where our existing beliefs are accepted without question.

We consume information from sources that tell us what we already expect to hear.

And when someone challenges those beliefs, we can simply dismiss them, block them, or retreat into a community where everyone assures us that we were right all along.

These environments are commonly called echo chambers.

And they offer something that can be very appealing.

Comfort.

There is comfort in having our opinions reinforced.

There is comfort in believing that the people around us understand the world exactly as we do.

There is comfort in never having to confront the possibility that something we believe might be mistaken.

But comfort and wisdom are not the same thing.

An echo chamber can make us increasingly confident without making us any more knowledgeable.

And that creates a dangerous situation.

Because confidence influences our decisions.

We make choices about our relationships, our work, our communities, and the people who depend upon us based upon what we believe to be true.

If those beliefs have never been seriously examined, how much confidence should we really place in them?

The Hávamál offers another perspective in stanza twenty-eight:

Wise shall he seem | who well can question,
And also answer well;
Nought is concealed | that men may say
Among the sons of men.

There are two abilities worth considering here.

The ability to question.

And the ability to answer.

Both require us to engage with ideas rather than merely defend our existing positions.

A person who asks thoughtful questions demonstrates a willingness to learn.

A person who can answer those questions demonstrates an ability to explain and examine what he believes.

And when those abilities come together, something valuable becomes possible.

An honest exchange of ideas.

That doesn’t mean every disagreement must end with someone changing their mind.

Quite the opposite.

Sometimes examining an opposing perspective reveals a weakness in our own understanding.

Perhaps we discover information we hadn’t considered.

Perhaps someone identifies a contradiction in our reasoning.

Perhaps we recognize that a conclusion we reached years ago no longer fits what we now know.

When that happens, we have an opportunity to change our position.

But sometimes the opposite occurs.

We listen carefully.

We examine the evidence.

We consider the reasoning being offered.

And after doing so, we conclude that our original position remains the most reasonable one.

That, too, can be valuable.

Because now our confidence rests upon something more substantial than familiarity or agreement.

Our belief has been examined.

It has been challenged.

And it has survived that examination.

The purpose of considering opposing perspectives isn’t necessarily to change what we believe.

It is to determine whether what we believe deserves our confidence.

That distinction matters.

Especially in a society where disagreement is so often treated as hostility.

We have developed an unfortunate tendency to assume that someone who disagrees with us must be ignorant, dishonest, or somehow morally deficient.

Certainly, some arguments are poorly reasoned.

Some people are dishonest.

And some claims are simply unsupported by evidence.

But disagreement itself establishes none of those things.

Two reasonable people can examine the same circumstances and reach different conclusions.

They may place different importance upon competing obligations.

They may have different experiences.

They may recognize different risks.

Or one may possess information the other lacks.

If we dismiss another person’s perspective before understanding it, we may never discover which of those possibilities applies.

This brings us to a principle that has long been important within Theodish thought: freedom of conscience.

At its heart, freedom of conscience recognizes that another person must be permitted to exercise their own judgment.

That doesn’t require us to agree with their conclusions.

It doesn’t require us to pretend that every belief is equally reasonable.

And it certainly doesn’t require us to abandon our own convictions.

It requires recognizing that another person’s conscience is not ours to command.

We can question.

We can challenge.

We can present evidence.

We can explain our reasoning.

But ultimately, each person must decide what they believe and accept responsibility for the consequences of those beliefs.

And if we expect that freedom for ourselves, we should consider what obligations accompany extending it to others.

There is a relationship here that is easy to overlook.

An honest conversation is itself a form of exchange.

One person offers a perspective.

Another offers questions, experience, or a different interpretation.

Both have an opportunity to gain something.

But that exchange requires a willingness to participate in good faith.

If one person enters the conversation determined that nothing could possibly change their thinking, the exchange becomes something else.

It becomes a performance.

The goal is no longer understanding.

The goal is winning.

And winning an argument is not necessarily the same as discovering the truth.

The Hávamál warns about another obstacle to wisdom in stanza twenty-two:

A paltry man | and poor of mind
At all things ever mocks;
For never he knows, | what he ought to know,
That he is not free from faults.

That final observation deserves attention.

He is not free from faults.

Neither are we.

And yet, how often do we encounter people who seem utterly convinced of their own intellectual superiority?

People who dismiss everyone who disagrees with them.

People whose confidence appears to rest primarily upon the approval of others who share their opinions.

People who mistake ridicule for reasoning.

There is a difference between confidence earned through experience, knowledge, and demonstrated competence, and arrogance built upon nothing more than repeated affirmation.

The first may provide a foundation for sound judgment.

The second can prevent judgment from developing at all.

But there’s a danger in discussing arrogance.

It is remarkably easy to recognize it in other people.

It is considerably more difficult to recognize it in ourselves.

We can listen to a discussion about intellectual humility and immediately begin identifying everyone we know who needs to hear it.

Our coworkers.

Our relatives.

The people arguing on television.

The strangers expressing opinions online.

And perhaps they do need to hear it.

But what about us?

What beliefs do we hold that we have never seriously questioned?

What subjects do we consider ourselves knowledgeable about without having examined the evidence?

When was the last time someone challenged one of our convictions and we genuinely considered whether they might have a point?

Sit with that question a moment, because the moment it describes comes for all of us.

Someone whose judgment we respect — a friend, a coworker, a man whose word carries weight with us — looks at something we believe and tells us we have it wrong.

Notice what happens in us before thought even gets a vote.

The heat rises. The defense starts forming. We begin gathering every argument we own, not to discover the truth, but to win.

Winning is the easy road. It asks nothing of us but volume.

The other road is harder. It asks us to go quiet. To ask the man across from us what he is seeing that we are not. To carry the question home and turn it over for days instead of seconds.

And sometimes — not often, but sometimes — a man does that work and discovers the challenge was right. Something he held for years does not survive honest examination.

Then comes the true test. Not the examining. The saying.

To stand in front of the same people who heard him defend the old position and say, plainly: I was wrong. No cushioning. No rewriting of history. Just the admission, out loud, where it costs something.

A man who can do that has not weakened his standing. He has proven the one thing that makes his word worth trusting — that his beliefs are conclusions he will re-examine, not furniture he will defend to the death.

Those questions are uncomfortable.

But discomfort is not necessarily a bad thing.

Sometimes it tells us that we have encountered something worth examining.

There is another aspect of wisdom that deserves consideration.

The difference between being willing to acknowledge a mistake and actively seeking the truth.

Recognizing that we might be wrong is an important beginning.

It opens the door to learning.

But deliberately seeking understanding takes us further.

It means we no longer view every challenge to our beliefs as something threatening.

We begin to recognize that an opposing perspective may offer us something valuable.

Even when we ultimately reject it.

We become interested not merely in defending our conclusions, but in understanding how we reached them.

And whether we should continue holding them.

This is not always an easy process.

Sometimes changing our minds requires admitting that we made poor decisions.

Sometimes it means acknowledging that someone we disagreed with understood something we did not.

Sometimes it requires reconsidering beliefs that have become closely connected to our identity.

And sometimes the available evidence simply isn’t enough to provide certainty.

We still have to make decisions.

We still have responsibilities.

And life rarely waits for us to achieve perfect understanding.

Wisdom doesn’t eliminate those difficulties.

It helps us approach them with greater awareness of what we know, what we don’t know, and what consequences our choices may create.

The Hávamál places enormous value upon wisdom itself.

In stanza ten, we find:

A better burden | may no man bear
For wanderings wide than wisdom;
It is better than wealth | on unknown ways,
And in grief a refuge it gives.

Consider what that means.

Wisdom is something we carry.

It accompanies us into unfamiliar circumstances.

It helps us recognize dangers, evaluate opportunities, and make decisions when the consequences matter.

But unlike a possession we can simply acquire and place upon a shelf, wisdom must be developed.

Through experience.

Through observation.

Through listening.

Through questioning.

And sometimes through discovering that we were wrong.

There is no shame inherent in learning something we did not previously understand.

The real question is what we do with that knowledge once we have it.

Do we allow it to improve our judgment?

Or do we reject it because accepting it would injure our pride?

Perhaps that’s one of the most important distinctions between knowledge and wisdom.

Knowledge concerns what we understand.

Wisdom concerns how we use that understanding.

And a person who refuses to learn places limits upon both.

So the next time we encounter an opinion that challenges our own, perhaps we should consider what opportunity that disagreement presents.

Not necessarily an opportunity to change our minds.

Not necessarily an opportunity to persuade someone else.

But an opportunity to examine the foundation upon which our beliefs rest.

We may discover that our convictions are sound.

We may discover that they require adjustment.

Or we may discover that the question is more complicated than we previously understood.

Any of those outcomes can contribute to wisdom.

But only if we’re willing to consider them.

And that leaves us with something worth asking ourselves.

When was the last time we deliberately challenged something we believed, not because someone forced us to defend it, but because we genuinely wanted to know whether it was true?

And if we discovered that we were wrong…

Would we have the courage to accept it?

Similar Posts

Welcome to the discussion.

We encourage open and honest conversation here. Ask questions, share what you think, disagree respectfully — that's how we learn from each other.

But remember: this is a grithstead — a place of frith and sanctuary. In the old way, a grithstead was ground where weapons were set aside and all who entered were under its protection. We hold this space to that same standard. Treat everyone here with the respect you'd show a guest in your home.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *